What is this? A page of suspense and action? Are we still reading the same story?
Our party can see black shapes climbing into their hollow in the darkness. Merry and Pippin fall to the ground, terrified, and Sam clutches helplessly at Frodo. Frodo, feeling the same fear, has a desire to put the ring on. Without much of a fight, he does so, and can see under the black riders’ robes. They are grey, gnarled old men, and the tallest and most frightening is coming his way. The lead Ringwraith springs at Frodo, and our hero cries out the name of Elbereth Gilthoniel.
Where is Aragorn? What is he doing to help? Uh…I don’t know. He’s plotting. Let’s say that he’s plotting something. But only because we like him.
Here’s where you realize that we’ve caught back on to the movie plot. That entire beginning to this chapter, with the four hobbits and Aragorn plodding along through forest and marsh? Totally just a montage in the film. This page and the next, which is only a short portion of a page to end the chapter, cover this entire attack, which the movie focuses on. It’s because we, as a society, like action.
We want to draw out the sequence where the Ringwraiths bear down on Frodo. It’s exciting. Hell, let’s place it on Weathertop to add something to the setting. Here in the book, we’re in like a little dip on the hillside. Not grand enough for Hollywood.
However, it is for this sudden shift that this book is genius. There’s the backstory. We’ve been over that. Tolkien poured most of his life’s work into creating a full history for Middle-earth. Then, all of a sudden, we have a driving moment of action. And both are good. We want to read both parts, not just skim whatever we find uninteresting.
At least, well, I want to read both parts. Maybe I shouldn’t speak for everyone. Sorry.
End of this chapter tomorrow!
“At that moment Frodo threw himself forward on the ground, and he heard himself crying aloud: O Elbereth! Gilthoniel! At the same…”